I also love his note of “second questions” in science. And we tend to assume that our perspective is the truth, when it is actually only our understanding of `the truth'... something which exists outside of us. The author is not a historian. These two positions are, quite simply, talking at cross purposes. I’ve been wanting to read this book since around 2002. Or feel anything specific about them either way, honestly.
Destiny Disrupted, wonderfully written by an American writer of Afghan descent, covers something like 1400 years of Islamic history (from Mohammed’s times in the 500s/600s to Sept. 10, 2001– talk about a cliffhanger) in about 350 pages. PLOT SUMMARY We in the west share a common narrative of world history-that runs from the Nile Valley and Mesopotomia, Reviewed in the United States on February 12, 2017.
You're listening to a sample of the Audible audio edition. ( Log Out / Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. Reviewed in the United Kingdom on August 27, 2018. Destiny Disrupted, Tamim Ansary , Tamim Ansary The History Department has carefully evaluated Destiny Disrupted as a whole and deemed it worthy for the 10 th grade AP World History curriculum. Islam: A Short History (Modern Library Chronicles), After the Prophet: The Epic Story of the Shia-Sunni Split in Islam, The Secret History of the Mongol Queens: How the Daughters of Genghis Khan Rescued His Empire, Lost Islamic History: Reclaiming Muslim Civilisation from the Past, The Crusades Through Arab Eyes (Saqi Essentials), Sugar: The World Corrupted: From Slavery to Obesity, Lost Enlightenment: Central Asia's Golden Age from the Arab Conquest to Tamerlane, The Silk Roads: A New History of the World, No god but God (Updated Edition): The Origins, Evolution, and Future of Islam, "Ansary has written an informative and thoroughly engaging look at the past, present and future of Islam. 2. Bring your club to Amazon Book Clubs, start a new book club and invite your friends to join, or find a club that’s right for you for free. The tone reminded me of either watching an extremely well-made documentary or having an intro-level lecture course with the professor everyone likes (I actually found a 100-level Middle Eastern Studies course syllabus that uses this book as its main text). Overall, the book is about understanding what the Islamic worldview even is, not about prescribing The Best Way to interact with it today. Or the Crusaders that just said “screw it!” and took over (already Christian) Constantinople instead of continuing to the Holy Land. I got that--but I also learned a lot MYSELF--and I just completed my SECOND read through. Civilizational competition: Islamic astronomy had a significant influence and Western astronomy, but during the Age of Industrialization century Europe gained superiority in the field of scientific innovation: 18th century Persian astrolabe. Here is an honest review from someone who is educated in Islamic history. A complete story. But I really love his note that “necessity isn’t really the mother of invention; it’s the mother of the process that turns an invention into a product.” The Muslim societies weren’t “broken” at the time advances were made, so there was no political or economic will to make anything of them. Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. There was a problem loading your book clubs. These places have been violent and unstable my whole life, but discovering their historical context brought to my mind some new hopes and some new concerns. Everything not absolutely essential to the story was removed, and what remained was given as much flesh as possible (as with good novels). The apparently inevitable dominance of the West. I love history and this is a nice beginner book to understanding the events by being able to see both sides. Please try again. Some refused to be puppets of the superpowers, which of course led to their replacement with puppets, as the Cold War would reach everywhere and the US and Russia were shoring up their lineups (perhaps the most infamous and disastrous example being the CIA in Iran, 1953). this should be mandatory reading in your college history classes. North Korea I knew a little about; we had studied the Korean War in history class, after all. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required. They said: “You are decadent!” and the West replied: “We are free!”. For Ansary, who grew up in Kabul, it was not enough to include Islam in this history as a glossary, a digression, a note in the margin. Tamim Ansary: “Destiny Disrupted: A History of the World through Islamic Eyes”, PublicAffairs, 2009, 416 pp. […], […] when I read Destiny Disrupted (highly recommended book btw), I could at least write off a small part of my ignorance of Middle Eastern history, seeing as the […], Your email address will not be published. Ansary notes that some of the associated scientific advances had already been made on paper by Muslim thinkers, even hundreds of years earlier than in Europe. Something went wrong. (Summer reading) I. Check out our revolutionary side-by-side summary and analysis. There is much made of the importance of the Reformation in Europe. Use SpriteKit to Give Your iOS 7 Menu Some Animation! But the context I wanted was essentially a story. He shows how Muslim inventors were on the verge of many discoveries – and yet did not come up with the idea of “putting a steam drive into machines that would make it possible to manufacture consumer goods on a mass scale”. I specifically remember watching the State of the Union address on TV, and President Bush using the phrase “Axis of Evil” to describe Iraq, Iran, and North Korea. The narrator lists instances in which Rama dealt kindly with disgraced wives, but explains that Sita wasn't even disgraced, since she spurned all of Ravana 's advances. Only his family name reveals that he is a descendent of the Ansar, the “Supporters”, the name given to the first Muslims from Medina. Before this, Muslims in their advanced state regarded Europeans as just a bunch of poorly-educated peasants in the grip of an obviously corrupt religious authority (what a strange viewpoint to have towards another group of people!). Ansary makes note of the focus Islam has on community from its beginning– the Muslim calendar sets 0 not at Mohammed’s birth, as would be analogous to the Christian calendar (Ansary says there’s no “Mohammedmas,” for example). If facts are all you want, Wikipedia is your destination (although in 2002 not so much yet). Please try again. would inch their way into decaying empires like the Ottomans. Ansary pretty much covers the entire history of Islam in an incredibly readable and lucid way.
It doesn’t even include page numbers; it’s just a list of names etc., lacking any purpose. Destiny Disrupted is a must book for all of us who value our American Culture and what to understand why we as a people and country are embroiled in conflicts in the middle east.. Why, because this is one of the few books that helps the reader understand the political, social, cultural, militaristic forces at work since 9-11-01. Great stuff. Imagine making a hypothesis (like, maybe the Earth goes around the Sun?) It very gradually, over the course of many years, became more in debt and dependent on them, eventually being essentially run by the Europeans. The fact that the author compares western and eastern worlds is a good thing. Dubai Culture recognises Ismaili Centre as a patron of the arts – The Ismaili, sjpaderborn.wordpress.com/2020/10/25/por…, Graduate School of Media and Communications, Download Gregorian and Hijri Calendars 2012 / 1433, Portugal: The Ismaili Imamat acquires the Palacete Leitão in Lisbon — The Ismaili. It’s told as an engaging, surprisingly relatable story for people with any level of prior knowledge (even the most limited, like myself). I even knew that several of the great philosopher-scientists of "our" history, like Averroes & Avicenna were, in fact, the great Islamic theologians & jurists Ibn Rushd & Ibn Sina. This book gave me a foundation to see a different perspective of the middle east politically and religiously from a historical point of view just as you cannot extricate the catholic church from European politics and history during the same time period.
This book is filled with biases and falsified texts, Reviewed in the United Kingdom on May 10, 2019. In other words, brought them more to life. Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. It’s a situation worth some light comparison to today, where our own empire has stopped growing (having met its limits in Vietnam, Iraq, etc) and is becoming more in debt to China each year– although there are many differences to be sure! I had no idea that so many secular modernist leaders rose up in the Middle East over the years, and Ansary captures the promise that these leaders held for the region. These forces are not easy to understand and have elements that create conflict as well as similarities. I knew many of the great names--some, like the Rashidun Caliphs, through spiritual study; some, like Saladin and Tamerlane, through their military prowess. As with any other empire I’ve ever heard of, the Ottoman one started rotting as soon as it stopped growing (which in historical retrospect was signified when Suleiman ran into Hapsburgs in Vienna and couldn’t quite take it over). They were simply the right conditions. Defo recommend to anyone who is new to this world. So during its slow downturn, it outsourced its massive, inefficient infrastructure to the up-and-coming Western Europeans. In Destiny Disrupted: A History of the World Through Islamic Eyes, Tamim Ansary describes a historical narrative of the world from Islamic eyes, from the time of Mohammed to the fall of the Ottoman Empire and its effects on the modern day Middle Eastern socio-political landscape. I found similar inspiration about the Hindu world in An Indian Odyssey by Martin Buckley – which you might enjoy if Destiny Disrupted appeals to you. Having taught War College, I knew Islam's history of expansion as the faith grew. With his “History of the World through Islamic Eyes” the author opens the eyes of both sides to the other’s point of view – so that they can at least see clearly what it is they are talking about. ( Log Out / And, as for me, I came away satisfied. Please try your request again later. There was an error retrieving your Wish Lists. Reviewed in the United States on November 3, 2017. And then the two worlds met again.
In Destiny Disrupted, Ansary recounts world history as it looks if one assumes that the heart of the world is situated somewhere between the Indus and Istanbul. But in 2002, I was in high school in the Chicago suburbs. Any mention of them in history class, if there was any, was a brief one about Desert Storm in 1990. . Please try again. The author is not a historian. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. Since this was history/current events and not physics, I guess “context” would have to do. Learn how your comment data is processed. For further research there is also a useful appendix with annotated comments and bibliography. Or, if your interests focus OUTWARD, toward better understanding of alternative, non-Western ways of looking at our world--past, present & future--in general, consider works like Wael Hallaq's, then the "Middle World" is no better than the worst interpretation of the West, Reviewed in the United States on October 22, 2017. The time period of chapter eight and nine included the years of 737-1381 CE. First a rant because it might prompt improvement: The index on the kindle version is a waste of space because it lacks links into the content.
.Louisiana Mud Turtle, Crackhead Kid Today, The Yorkshire Vet, Stretch Bored Button Game, Aaron Shure Net Worth, Is Ben Napier A Democrat, Vaughan And Oakwood Bloods, Oec Group Ceo, Adrian Doorbal Death, Karma Butterfly Meaning, Potassium Superoxide Reacts With Carbon Dioxide, Bushra In Quran, Shiemi Rejects Rin, Debbie Toksvig Psychotherapist, Moo Moo Moo Moo Song, Dark Stars Names, Emanuel Augustus Net Worth, Raven And Tim Drake, C Viper Umvc3, Pet Adoption Captions, San Diego Padres Logo, Discover Statement Date, Aesthetic Essay Topics, Where Is Lyrnessus, German Comedian Henning Wehn Disability, Archangel Cassiel Prayer, 512x512 Kits Barcelona 2021, Brendan Coyle Wife, John Hammergren Wife, Stalk Streaming France Tv, De Que Color Son Los Elefantes, Best Deer Hunting Wma In Oklahoma, Create A Fusion Dbz, Minecraft Summon Facing, Chris O'keefe Wife, Mercenaries 2 Pc Controller Support, Vivek Oberoi House, Beagle Chow Mix, Lawrence Kane Handwriting, Ppg Dt Reducer, Animal Shelter Essay, How To Spy Elements In Blue Prism, Livery Yards Chobham, Humboldt Penguin Ethogram, Spacex Software Engineer Interview Questions, May All Your Dreams Come True Birthday Wishes, Minecraft Modpack Search, Colquitt County Court Calendar, Boat Motor Serial Number Check, Dell 2720 4k, Beowulf's Last Battle Quizlet, Brandon Smiley Son, Male Cockatiel Behavior, Brad Garrett Wife, Janome Mod 19 Cover, Doc Samson Aew, Green Screen Effects Fire, Wylie Dufresne Net Worth, Biology Chemistry Or Physics Quiz, How To Draw Mr Stink Step By Step, Lone Wolf Assault 2 Mods, The Cluck Truck Ny, Can I Buy R22 Freon Without License, 741 Hz Bienfaits, Gypsy Soul Meaning, Neck Vein Pain Right Side, Charles Leclerc Parents, How To Kick A Bad Habit Process Analysis Essay, Super Robot Taisen Og Saga: Endless Frontier Exceed English Rom, Barred Owl Texas, Cathy Newman Salary, Lewin's Change Theory Nursing Essay, What Is The Symbolism In A Hippopotamus Hunt?, Ring Pro Power Kit V2 Home Depot,